How to Decide If I Should Repair or Replace My Roof

Jul 27, 2022Blog, Roof Repair, Roof Replacement

Our roofs are the barriers that protect us from the outside world.  They play an important role in keeping our homes and families safe from the elements.  When a roof is damaged it’s important to take care of the damage immediately to ensure the best possible outcomes, but how do you know if you should repair your roof or replace it completely?

Factors That Will Help You Decide Whether to Repair or Replace Your Roof

When your roof is damaged there are several important factors that you and your roofing contractor in Branson will weigh to determine whether it makes more sense to repair the damage or replace the roof.

best roofing company Branson, MO

Age of Roof

All roofing materials have an expected lifespan.  If your roof is practically new it would make more sense to repair the damage if possible.  On the other hand, if your roof is only a year or two out from the end of its expected life it will likely be more cost-effective to replace the roof.

Type of Damage

The type of damage to the roof may make a difference in your decision.  Even if the damage covers a good portion of the roof it might be more reasonable to repair it if it’s something easily repaired like missing shingles.  If the damage is more extensive like a branch that has fallen through the roof it could be more difficult and costly to repair even if only a small portion of the roof was damaged.

Area of Roof Affected

How much of your roof was affected by the damage?  In general, if more than 30% of the roof was damaged it will make more sense to invest in a new roof.  Obviously, as mentioned above, other factors can play a role in this.

Are You Staying?

Is this your forever home or are you planning to sell it?  This can impact your decision in a few different ways.  If you’re planning to stay you’ll likely be in less of a hurry and can manage to wait for a full roof replacement if it is needed.  If you’re in the process of selling the home you may need to bump up the timeline and find a faster solution like a roof repair.  If you’re planning to sell the home, but it’s not on the market yet a roof replacement might be a better choice for the value it could add to your home.

trusted Branson, MO roof repair experts

Advantages and Disadvantages of Roof Repair

Opting to repair your roof can come with many advantages and some disadvantages.  A roof repair is less costly and time-consuming than a full replacement and it can help extend the lifespan of your roof.  On the other hand, it can sometimes be difficult to match your old roofing materials to your new ones which is unsightly and a poorly done repair can lead to more problems in the long run.

best roof replacement company Branson, MO

Advantages and Disadvantages of Roof Replacement

Choosing a full roof replacement for your roof also has its pros and cons.  A full roof replacement will address all roofing problems, even ones that might be hidden.  It will also add value to your home with enhanced curb appeal and improved energy efficiency.  Additionally, a new roof will last much longer than a repair.  The biggest drawbacks to a roof replacement are the increased costs and longer timeline when compared to a roof repair.

Still having trouble deciding on the best course of action for your home?  Call The Micham Roofing Company and let us help!